“Where are you from?” enquired the 83 year old ‘lady in waiting’ of a black woman at a charity event at the palace. Henceforth, I’ll call the ‘lady in waiting’, Lady W
“Hackney,” replied the woman.
Not receiving the answer she wanted, Lady W persisted,
“No, but where are you really from?”
This line of questioning continued in an unusually offensive manner. Eventually, the hapless woman at the receiving end finished the conversation thus:
“No Lady. I am of African heritage, Caribbean descent and British nationality.”
The media got hold of the story. Lady W was subsequently sacked for this overt act of racism and the palace apologised profusely to the victim. Old story. But what’s it got to do with me?
Occasionally, I too get asked where I am from. A typical conversation is as follows:
“So, Gopi, where are you from?”
“Southampton,” I reply while observing the other person’s facial expression to gauge if my response was satisfactory. Often, I spot a fleeting look of disappointment on my interlocutor’s face. In this case, I quickly add,
“I am originally from India. I have lived in this country since 1992.” I have this habit of supplying more information than solicited, but I find it sometimes leads to interesting conversations.
“India? Fascinating place. I was there on vacation last year…” and the conversation takes off. I am hanging on their every word, wallowing in nostalgia for my home country while they relive their magical holiday. Everyone is happy. The question, “where are you from?” is, more often than not, an opening gambit to start a conversation. In the vast majority of instances, no racism is intended, and none taken.
Let me illustrate with a couple of anecdotes.
I visited Tripoli, Libya, in the early years of my sailing career. After calling at Aden (my first foreign port, and then capital of Yemen) and transiting the Suez Canal, my ship called at Tripoli. Libya was a wealthy nation at the time. It was a decade before the Lockerby bombing and subsequent sanctions that eviscerated the country’s economy.
One evening, I was wandering aimlessly in Tripoli taking in the sights of its palm-lined avenues, the din and smells of its souks. Near the main square, I spotted a middle-aged man leaning against a flashy sports car, enjoying a cigarette. He looked like the carbon copy of my favourite uncle back home. The sight of this man simultaneously made me homesick and raised my spirits. Approaching him, I asked,
“Are you from India?”
The uncle-lookalike gave me a long hard stare and replied,
“And if I am not? What will you do to me?”
I apologised profusely and explained why I had assumed he was from India. He was only half impressed with my grovelling. With the special trait of people from the sub-continent – of ticking someone off while also giving them advice, he said,
“I am from Pakistan. Never ask anyone such a question in the future.”
Thank you my Pakistani uncle for this life lesson and for the coffee and cake you subsequently bought me. I was a wiser 22 year old after that incident and always took special care while attempting to establish someone’s country of origin. The habit of trying to understand where someone is ‘really’ from, their human provenance – so to speak, never left me.
Some fifteen years later, I decided to hang up my sailing boots and settle ashore. I ended up working for the University of Sheffield in their Computer Science department. A colleague with a very distinct guttural accent used to work in an adjoining office. He didn’t sound anything like the locals and rarely smiled or acknowledged my presence. I was only coming to grips with the strong ‘owts’ and ‘nowts’ of the ‘Broad Yorkshire’ accent. My curiosity to establish his ethnicity egged me on. After some heavy digging, I concluded that he could be Scottish. I had never come across a Scotsman until then. Keen to validate my tentative conclusion, I asked,
“Is that a Scottish accent?”
“How did ya guess?” he replied half growling, half smiling, in what I know today to be the Glaswegian accent.
On that occasion, however, his sarcasm was lost on me. Nevertheless, we became good friends. He regaled me with extraordinary tales about the Loch Ness monster, the highlands and the lowlands and nuances of single malt whiskies from these lands. “Oh aye! It’s the water,” he used to say. I found myself working in Glasgow some ten years later, thanks perhaps to my obsessive curiosity that led to a fruitful friendship with a Glaswegian.
And finally I retired in 2022. On a balmy summer morning, I was cycling with a group of some fifteen others as part of a local club ride in Southampton. When we reached a quiet part of Hampshire, without much traffic, someone rode up and cycled alongside me. After mutual introductions, he asked,
“So, where do you come from?”
“India,” I replied assuming he wanted to have a conversation with me about India and so jumping straight to the right answer. Except, it was the wrong answer. He chuckled.
“It’s a long way to cycle!” he said, “I meant where did you start from this morning?”
So, in conclusion, establishing someone’s origin is fraught with danger. It can go wrong in many ways if one is not careful. Human communication is imperfect and often words only convey a fraction of what we want to say. It is easy enough to misconstrue the language of others.
This is not condoning the brazenly racist approach of Lady W – her line of questioning was completely out of order. But she was the exception – a rotten apple in a basket full of good ones.








